As the only common cardiovascular
condition increasing in incidence, prevalence, and mortality,
congestive heart failure (CHF) has been the subject of increased
interest among researchers evaluating various therapeutic options on
clinical endpoints. Treating major risk factors like hypertension
and atherosclerosis effectively has been shown to help prevent CHF,
delay progression, and improve survival of CHF.
Diuretics remain
essential for patients with fluid retention; but they typically fail
to prevent progression or improve prognosis. Addition of digoxin in
symptomatic CHF due to systolic dysfunction tends to retard
progression without improving survival. Addition of
angiotensin-converting enzyme (ACE) inhibitors, on the other hand,
has been shown to both decrease mortality and retard progression;
and they are recommended as early therapy in left ventricular
dysfunction, whether symptomatic or asymptomatic. Combinations of
hydralazine and isosorbide dinitrate are typically less effective
than ACE inhibitors.
Digoxin can reduce
the risk of exacerbation irrespective of rhythm, systolic function,
severity of CHF, or addition of ACE inhibitors; but other oral
inotropic agents like amrinone, pimobendan, vesnarinone, and
ibopamine increase mortality significantly and fail to improve other
clinical endpoints during long-term therapy. While amlodipine and
mibefradil appear relatively safe treatments of angina or
hypertension in CHF, calcium antagonists, in general may actually
increase mortality in CHF. Use of amiodarone is gaining popularity
for patients with sustained ventricular tachycardia or ventricular
fibrillation; but antiarrhythmic agents should generally be avoided
in the absence of arrhythmia.
The beta-blockers,
carvedilol and metoprolol, have been shown to prolong survival and
retard progression in combination with digoxin, diuretics, and ACE
inhibitors; and recent studies support the use of spironolactone to
current treatment recommendations.
Halawa
B.
Trends
in pharmacological treatment of congestive heart failure]
Pol Merkuriusz Lek
1999 Mar 6:33 152-6.
Background
Autonomic Nervous Involvement Elevated
plasma levels of norepinephrine (NE) are a hallmark of CHF, both at
rest and during exercise, that is associated with deteriorating
prognosis. The heart and kidneys produce about 60% of the excess.
The ratio of release rate versus clearance rate (spillover) in
symptomatic failure is twice that of non-CHF individuals, with a
decrease in clearance of about 30%. This elevation is due in part,
to a loss of tonic inhibitory control of central sympathetic activity
from cardiopulmonary baroreceptors in the failing heart, resulting in
a generalized increase in basal sympathetic outflow, significant for
at least these two important reasons:
1. Apoptosis -- Unlike in other
tissues, where cells undergo mitosis to replenish the ranks of
demised cells, myocytes lose this ability between 3 and 6 months
after birth. Thus, as myocytes die, they are not replenished.
Since the individual’s complement of myocytes remains the same
chronological age as the individual, the likelihood of developing
CHF increases with age from about 18% in one’s fifties to almost
60% by age 70. Apoptosis, or programmed cell suicide, is a
genetically programmed process abnormally triggered by several
aspects of CHF. Elevations in levels of angiotensin II and other
growth factors, persistent elevations in cardiac intracellular
calcium (due to dilated cardiomyopathy), monocyte hypoxia (due to
left ventricular hypertrophy), and elevations in basal sympathetic
outflow all accelerate rates of apoptosis.
2. The heart depends primarily upon
beta-1 adrenergic support to meet both basal and sustained
hemodynamic demands. The constant exposure to adrenergic
stimulation by elevated NE levels a) reduces the sensitivity and
response of cardiac functional beta-1 receptors, b) reduces the
production and number of functional receptors, and c) perpetuates
cellular calcium overload, leading to cardiotoxicity.
The Renin-Angiotensin-Aldosterone System
The roles of the
Renin-Angiotensin-Aldosterone system in regulating 1) fluid and
electrolyte balance, 2) vascular smooth muscle tone, and 3) growth of
smooth and cardiac muscle make it a logical target for
pharmacological intervention in congestive heart failure (CHF) as
well as hypertension. In brief:
Renin, an enzyme produced and stored in
the renal juxtaglomerular apparatus, catalyzes production of
Angiotensin I (a peptide) from Angiotensinogen, a glycoprotein
supplied from the liver, kidney, brain, and lipoid and other tissues.
Angiotensin Converting Enzyme (ACE) is a non-specific enzyme that
catalyzes hydrolysis of numerous peptides in various tissues; but of
course the conversion important to this discussion is that of
Angiotensin I to Angiotensin II, the primary vasoactive entity in the
system. Angiotensin II also stimulates adrenal delivery of
aldosterone, which helps to regulate sodium/potassium/fluid
homeostasis by stimulating potassium secretion and sodium
reabsorption.
Table 1 (under construction)
Kidney Renin Angiotensin
Converting Enzyme
Angiotensinogen
Angiotensin I Angiotensin II
Adrenals
Vasoconstriction
Aldosterone
Angiotensin II Pharmacology in CHF While Angiotensin I-7, Angiotensin III
and Angiotensin IV also have some activity, Angiotensin II is by far
the most active and exerts its pharmacological effects primarily on
AT1 receptors. Angiotensin III exerts effects similar to but
generally weaker than those of Angiotensin II; Angiotensin I-7
exerts comparable effects in the central nervous system, but none
peripherally; and Angiotensin IV is believed to help regulate
cerebral blood flow, acting only on AT4 receptors there. AT2
receptors, most prolific in neonatal tissues are thought to function
in growth regulation and vascular smooth muscle differentiation.
Recent studies suggest that the AT2 receptor may have some
counter-regulatory protective function involving bradykinin and
nitric oxide against the antinatriuretic and pressor actions of AT1
stimulation.
Angiotensin II increases the release
of norepinephrine in response to low-frequency sympathetic
stimulation, acting at presynaptic receptors of postganglionic
sympathetic neurons. It also has direct stimulatory action on
sympathetic ganglia and the adrenal medulla, the latter increasing
aldosterone secretion without increasing glucocorticoid production.
Increases in both arterial and peripheral blood pressure are thought
to result from central efferent sympathetic activity as well as
direct receptor-mediated contraction of vascular smooth muscle.
Normal increases in circulating
aldosterone and angiotensin are essential for maintaining homeostasis
as changes in sodium and water volume occur. Abnormal sustained
elevations, though, disrupt the homeostasis to cause hypertension and
CHF. Resulting “salt-avid” renal function leads to both
intravascular and interstitial fluid overload that overworks the
heart; while peripheral edema and congested organs tax the whole
circulatory system, reducing the efficiency of most organ systems.
While reflex bradycardia often causes reduced cardiac output,
Angiotensin II increases vascular endothelial permeability to
contribute to edema. Angiotensin II also tends to generate
hyperplasia of cardiac fibroblasts and myocytes and vascular smooth
muscle; and it perpetuates hypertrophy via protein deposition in
these tissues as well. The heart and vasculature undergo progressive
changes that thus perpetuate the condition. Angiotensin II often
increases thirst by central nervous stimulation and exerts
antinatriuretic and antidiuretic effects to ultimately increase fluid
volume, all further contributing to the pathophysiologies of
hypertension and CHF.
Casis L. The
Renin-Angiotensin System and Other Vasoactive Substances. Modern
Pharmacolgy With Clinical Applications, Fifth Edition.
Little, Brown and Company, 1997.
Yamada
H,
Akishita
M,
Ito
M,
Tamura
K,
Daviet
L,
Lehtonen
JY,
Dzau
VJ,
Horiuchi
MAT2
receptor and vascular smooth muscle cell differentiation in vascular
development. Hypertension
1999 Jun 33:6 1414-9. Siragy
HM,
Inagami
T,
Ichiki
T,
Carey
RM.
Sustained hypersensitivity to angiotensin II and its mechanism in
mice lacking the subtype-2 (AT2) angiotensin receptor. Proc
Natl Acad Sci U S A
1999 May 25 96:11 6506-10.
Weber
T. Aldosterone and spironolactone in Heart Failure. NEJM Editorial.
http://www.nejm.org/content/weber/1.asp. Downloaded 7-30-99.
Spironolactone
Added to CHF Treatment Recommendations Treatment
strategies aim to increase survival by preventing or delaying
progression. Diuretics have long been the standard first-line
therapy, as reducing fluid overload is essential for ameliorating
symptoms; but diuretics generally fail to arrest progression or
improve survival. Having recognized the involvement of Angiotensin
II and aldosterone in CHF, established treatment guidelines have
included an ACE inhibitor and a loop diuretic, either with or without
digoxin for New York Heart Association CHF classes II or IV. Studies
have shown the value of such combinations, with both progression and
mortality effectively reduced by adding an ACE inhibitor to the
standard regimen. Where systolic dysfunction is present,
combinations of digoxin and a diuretic often retard progression but
fail to improve survival. ACE inhibitor therapy is now recommended
early in treatment of even asymptomatic left ventricular failure.
The assumption is that limiting the production of Angiotensin II
logically limits the ensuing production of aldosterone as well, thus
attacking the problem from several directions and helping to restore
homeostasis.
Other
studies, though, have shown ACE inhibition only partially and
transiently effective at blocking production of Angiotensin II and
ensuing reductions in aldosterone levels. Identification of other
pathways utilizing enzyme systems other than ACE in various tissues
to generate Angiotensin II have helped to explain such breakthrough
production. These avenues have been identified in the heart, the
aorta, and other vasculature and utilize tissue plasminogen activator
(tPA), cathepsin G, tonin, elastase, and chymase to produce
Angiotensin II directly from angiotensinogen without the intermediary
angiotensin I, completely subverting the efficacy of ACE inhibitory
agents. Recent evidence suggests that ACE inhibitors actually
reflexively increase total tissue and serum ACE concentrations. Since
doses of ACE inhibitors are frequently limited by side effects, and
in light of the above-mentioned mechanisms of angiotensin II escape,
addition of an AT1 receptor antagonist to the regimen can both
improve and prolong reductions. Substitution of the AT1 receptor
antagonist (as opposed to addition to existing regimens) can also
often provide improvement over ACE inhibition alone.
Aldosterone
levels in the CHF patient, that may approach 20 times those in normal
individuals, may remain high in spite of all efforts to suppress the
action of Angiotensin II, as other reasons for aldosterone elevations
become important factors.
* Aldosterone
secretion independent of Angiotensin II activity continues in
response to potassium levels.
* Sodium
restriction below 3 grams per day, and even physical activity can
increase renin production beyond the capabilities of ACE inhibition
and/or AT1 blockade to compensate. * CHF often
reduces the capacity of the liver to eliminate aldosterone and its
active metabolites effectively. As with
Angiotensin II, long-term elevations in aldosterone levels stimulate
proliferation of fibroblasts to remodel the heart, blood vessels, and
other organs.
A
new study reported in the New England Journal of Medicine has
evaluated the benefits suppressing the effects of this breakthrough
aldosterone with spironolactone. In CHF patients already taking an
ACE inhibitor, a diuretic, and possibly digoxin, adding
spironolactone, even in small doses, was shown to reduce the risk of
death by 30%. Further it reduced hospitalizations for progressing
CHF by 35%. The
results are considered so important that the NEJM posted the report
on its web site in advance of publication, a measure taken only
rarely when a report is expected to greatly impact the lives of many
people.
http://www.nejm.org/content/pitt/1.asp
Hawawa B. Trends in
pharmacological treatment of congestive heart failure.
Pol Merkuriusz Lek. 1999 Mar 6:33 152-6.
Oparil S. Long-term
morbidity and mortality trials with amlodipine. J
Cardiovasc Pharmacol. 1999 33 suppl 2 S1-6.
Hamroff G, Katz SD,
Mancini D, Blaufarb I, Bijou R, Patel R, Jondeau G, Olivari MT,
Thomas S, LeJemtel TH. Addition of angiotensin II receptor blockade
to maximal angiotensin-converting enzyme inhibition improves exercise
capacity in patients with severe congestive heart failure.
Circulation. 1999 Mar
2 99:8 990-2.
Bertram Pitt, Faiez Zannad, Willem
J. Remme, Robert Cody, Alain Castaigne, Alfonso Perez, Jolie
Palensky, Janet Wittes. The Effect of Spironolactone on Morbidity and
Mortality in Patients with Severe Heart Failure. NEJM web site.
Downloaded 7/30/99.
Brunner-La Rocca HP,
Vaddadi G, Esler MD. Recent insight into therapy of congestive heart
failure: focus on ACE inhibition and angiotensin-II antagonism. J
Am Coll Cardiol. 1999 apr 33:5 1163-73.
Stanek E, Munger M. Heart
Failure. Pharmacotherapy Self-Assessment
Program, Third Edition. American College of
Clinical Pharmacy, 1998. 73-96.
Beta-Blockers in CHF Beta-blockers have been long avoided
in CHF due to their negative inotropic tendencies; but some patients
with CHF may benefit from adding specific beta-blockers to standard
regimens, as much of the myocardial damage seen with CHF may be
related to sympathetic activation.
Though
beta-blockers are not recommended as first-line therapy and should
not be used for acute failure, studies have shown symptomatic and
hemodynamic improvements with beta-1 selective agents, particularly
among patients with idiopathic dilated cardiomyopathy. Strong
evidence suggests that beta-blockers retard progression of left
ventricular dilatation and even improve left ventricular ejection
fraction after several months of treatment, with predictive value for
survival. Patients with NYHA II-III CHF due to nonischemic cause are
particularly apt to benefit from beta-blockade.
Metoprolol, as a selective beta-1
blocker, is often used as adjunctive therapy in CHF. Carvedilol is a
multiple-action neurohormonal agent that bears the official
indication for CHF, and with non-selective beta effects as well as
alpha-adrenergic blockade, it is effective in nonselective
beta-blockade and vasodilation. Via blockade of beta1-, beta2-, and
alpha1-adrenoceptors, carvedilol reduces total peripheral vascular
resistance and preload without significantly reducing cardiac output
or causing reflex tachycardia.
Formation of oxygen free radicals is
associated with apoptosis, which is implicated in the continued loss
of myocardial cells and causing progressive decrease in left
ventricular function. Since carvedilol is a potent antioxidant, it
may actually prevent some of the damage produced by oxygen radicals
to inhibit apoptosis in the myocardium. In clinical trials,
carvedilol decreased mortality by 65%.
A significant
correlation is observed between plasma immunoreactive endothelin-1
(ET-1) levels and the severity of CHF. Carvedilol also directly
inhibits the biosynthesis of endothelin-1. Endothelins, the most
potent vasoconstrictors known, are currently subjects of intense
study. The 3 endothelins are neurohormonal peptides (ET1, ET2, and
ET3) with different affinities for 2 major known receptors (ETA and
ETB). Elevated levels of ET-1 are seen in CHF, with known association
with positive inotropic effects and to induction of hypertrophy in
cardiomyocytes. In addition, both the ETA- and ETB-receptor systems
are greatly accelerated in the failing heart.
ET-1 is produced
from big ET-1 by endothelin-converting enzyme (ECE), and elevated
plasma levels of both big ET-1 and ET-1 are negatively associated
with survival in patents with CHF, similar to the situation with the
Angiotensins and aldosterone. Elevations in endogenous ET-1 levels
produce arterial vasoconstriction, slow LV relaxation, and depress LV
contractile performance. In one recent animal study, ETA receptor
antagonism produced greater in CHF than ECE inhibition, but ECE
inhibition reduced production of neurohumoral factors activated in
proportion to CHF severity. ET-1 also plays an important role in
cardiomyopathy, so ETA antagonists may help reduce progression of CHF
due to cardiomyopathy.
One recent study
estimates the cost of improved survival because of carvedilol therapy
at some $29,000 per year on a single-patient basis. In spite of all
the apparent advantages of carvedilol, one recent study discovered
virtually no difference between outcomes with carvedilol and
metoprolol. Both reduced mortality and progression, but metoprolol,
at substantially lower cost, produced the same results as the more
costly agent. The theoretical advantages of the multiple-action
neurohormonal agent evidently do not add up to more effective therapy
or superior outcomes.
Kukin
ML,
Kalman
J,
Charney
RH,
Levy
DK,
Buchholz-Varley
C,
Ocampo
ON,
Eng
C.
Prospective, randomized comparison of effect of long-term treatment
with metoprolol or carvedilol on symptoms, exercise, ejection
fraction, and oxidative stress in heart failure. Circulation
1999 May 25 99:20 2645-51.
Böhler
S,
Saubadu
S,
Scheldewaert
R,
Figulla
HR.
Betaxolol versus carvedilol in chronic heart failure (BETACAR
study). Rationale and design. Arzneimittelforschung
1999 Apr 49:4 311-7. Vanderhoff
BT,
Ruppel
HM,
Amsterdam
PB.
Carvedilol: the new role of beta blockers in congestive heart
failure. Am Fam
Physician 1998
Nov 1 58:7 1627-34, 1641-2. Ruffolo
RR Jr,
Feuerstein
GZ.
Neurohormonal activation, oxygen free radicals, and apoptosis in the
pathogenesis of congestive heart failure. J
Cardiovasc Pharmacol
1998 32 Suppl 1 S22-30.
Kobayashi
T,
Miyauchi
T,
Sakai
S,
Kobayashi
M,
Yamaguchi
I,
Goto
K,
Sugishita
Y.
Expression of endothelin-1, ETA and ETB receptors, and ECE and
distribution of endothelin-1 in failing rat heart. Am
J Physiol 1999
Apr 276:4 Pt 2 H1197-206. Wada
A,
Tsutamoto
T,
Ohnishi
M,
Sawaki
M,
Fukai
D,
Maeda
Y,
Kinoshita
M.
Effects of a specific endothelin-converting enzyme inhibitor on
cardiac, renal, and neurohumoral functions in congestive heart
failure: comparison of effects with those of endothelin A receptor
antagonism. Circulation
1999 Feb 2 99:4 570-7. Yamauchi-Kohno
R,
Miyauchi
T,
Hoshino
T,
Kobayashi
T,
Aihara
H,
Sakai
S,
Yabana
H,
Goto
K,
Sugishita
Y,
Murata
S.
Role of endothelin in deterioration of heart failure due to
cardiomyopathy in hamsters: increase in endothelin-1 production in
the heart and beneficial effect of endothelin-A receptor antagonist
on survival and cardiac function. Circulation
1999 Apr 27 99:16 2171-6. Onishi
K,
Ohno
M,
Little
WC,
Cheng
CP.
Endogenous endothelin-1 depresses left ventricular systolic and
diastolic performance in congestive heart failure. J
Pharmacol Exp Ther
1999 Mar 288:3 1214-22. Ohlstein
EH,
Arleth
AJ,
Storer
B,
Romanic
AM.
Carvedilol inhibits endothelin-1 biosynthesis in cultured human
coronary artery endothelial cells. J
Mol Cell Cardiol
1998 Jan 30:1 167-73. Delea
TE,
Vera-Llonch
M,
Richner
RE,
Fowler
MB,
Oster
G.
Cost effectiveness of carvedilol for heart failure. Am
J Cardiol 1999
Mar 15 83:6 890-6 .
Kukin
ML,
Kalman
J,
Charney
RH,
Levy
DK,
Buchholz-Varley
C,
Ocampo
ON,
Eng
C.
Prospective, randomized comparison of effect of long-term treatment
with metoprolol or carvedilol on symptoms, exercise, ejection
fraction, and oxidative stress in heart failure. Circulation
1999 May 25 99:20 2645-51.